ORGANSCHAFTEN: Vereinigung für ästhetische Dermatologie und Lasermedizin e.V.
Deutsche Gesellschaft für Ästhetische Dermatologie
Österreichische Gesellschaft für Ärztliche Kosmetologie und Altersforschung der Haut
Bockshornsamen + Mikronährstoffe:
Wirksamkeit eines Nahrungsergänzungsmittels gegen Haarausfall
of a food supplement against hair loss
Christiane Schulz, Stephan Bielfeldt, Dr. Jürgen Reimann
Haarausfall, Haarwachstum, Bockshornklee, Bockshorn+Mikro-
nährstoff Haarkapseln Arcon-Tisane
plus, Phototrichogramm, kli-
nische Studie, Nagelgesundheit
Haarverlust, dünner werdendes Haar, schlecht wachsende Haare
und kraftlose oder stumpfe Haare sind bekannte Beschwerden in
der klinischen Dermatologie. Daher gibt es einen Bedarf an Produk-
ten zur Unterstützung des Haarwachstums oder die regulierend in
den Haarzyklus eingreifen. Im Rahmen einer randomisierten, Pla-
cebo-kontrollierten klinischen Studie wurde die Wirksamkeit eines,
auf Bockshornkleesamen basierenden Nahrungsergänzungsmittels
gegen Haarausfall überprüft. Die Ergebnisse zeigen eine erfolgrei-
che Behandlung bei leichtem bis mäßigem Haarausfall bei Frauen
und Männern. Weiterhin zeigt das Präparat positive Effekte auf das
Hair growth depends on a com-
plex and precisely controlled
process, which is not fully under-
stood. It is a cyclical process,
involving synthesis, elongation
and finally shedding of the hair
shaft. Three phases are recog-
nized in this cycle, namely the
anagen (growth), catagen (regres-
sion) and telogen (rest) phases.
Shedding of the hair shaft occurs
at a time called telogenesis.
After telogenesis, a latency
period may be present before a
new hair shaft emerges at the skin surface. In normal states it is esti-
mated that 85–90 % of scalp hairs are in anagen, with the majority
of the remainder in telogen state [4, 6, 11]. If this balance in hair
growth cycle is impaired effluvium occurs . This can be caused
due to complex interactions which may involve molecular mecha-
nisms, angiogenesis, micro-inflammation, neuroendocrine influences
as well as environmental impact, microorganisms and nutritional
Hair loss, hair thinning, poorly growing hair and powerless or dull
hair are common complaints in clinical dermatology. Therefore it is
desirable to have products, which support the hair growing process
and control some of the disturbances in the hair cycle dynamics. The
aim of the study was to investigate the efficacy of a fenugreek seeds
extract containing food supplement* against hair loss. The efficacy
was evaluated over time and in comparison to placebo.
hair loss, hair growth, fenugreek, Bockshorn+Mikronährstoff
plus, phototrichogram, clinical study,
Hair loss, hair thinning, poorly growing hair and powerless or dull
hair are common complaints in clinical dermatology. There is a
need for products, which support the hair growing process and con-
trol some of the disturbances in the hair cycle dynamics. In context
of a randomised, placebo-controlled clinical trial efficacy of a fenu-
greek seeds containing food supplement against hair loss is evalu-
ated. The results indicate a successful treatment of low to moder-
ate hair loss in women and men. Additionally, positive effects on
hair growth were demonstrated.
Fig. 1: Fenugreek
(Trigonella foenum-graceum L.).
he verum preparation used in this study is a fenugreek seeds
extract containing food supplement, which additionally contains
micronutrients like hair active B-vitamins, antioxidants and trace
elements. Fenugreek (Trigonella foenum-graceum L.) (fig. 1) is an
annual herb of leguminosea. Fenugreek is native to Southern
Europe, the Mediterranean region and Western Asia. Seeds of fenu-
greek contain a wide range of active ingredients like saponins, espe-
cially derivatives of diosgenin, yamogenin and gitogenin, alkaloids
trigonelline), flavonoids, vitamins and fiber galactomannan etc
10]. Its seeds have a strong aroma and somewhat bitter in taste. It
has a long history as both a culinary and medicinal herb in the
ancient world. Beneficial properties of fenugreek seeds have
attracted wide attention in the recent past due to their therapeutic
potential, including its use as hypoglycemic, antiulcerogenic, hypo-
cholesterolemic and antihypertensive agent [1, 3, 13]. Beyond, it is
used in Ayurvedic medicine . Up to now, all active ingredients
responsible for the possible observed effects are not identified yet.
In monography of fenugreek a dosage of 6 g / day is quoted for oral
use and 50 g powdered drug in 1/4 l water for external use.
Positive effects of fenugreek on hair growth are known, however, the
mechanism is not characterized. It is discussed that fenugreek inter-
acts in a physiologic way by stimulating blood circulation to hair fol-
licles and steroid saponins are expected to interact with DHT (dihy-
drotestosterone) metabolism. One reason for male and female
pattern hair loss is thought to be due to the effects of DHT on geneti-
cally predisposed hair follicles. Binding of DHT to the hair follicle
results in gradual miniaturization of the hair and eventual hair loss.
A fenugreek containing product is already successfully on the market
since 1987. Now the formulation shall be further improved with addi-
tional micronutrients: vitamins and trace element compounds. In the
following clinical study its efficacy against hair loss shall be scientif-
The study was conducted as a mono-centric, randomised, double-
blind, placebo controlled clinical study. Prior study start, the study
design was approved by an independent ethics committee. Volun-
teers were screened for there eligibility to take part in the clinical
trial according to in- and exclusion criteria and enrolled after
informed consent. 60 volunteers (30 men and 30 women) with mild
to moderate hair loss ingested the test preparations (2 capsules
daily) over a period of 6 months. Additionally 6 volunteers were
enrolled two months after start of clinical trial because of drop outs
due to private reasons. In total, 53 volunteers successfully finished
the clinical trial. Every two months there was a dermatological
assessment of hair loss, a questionnaire and the assessment of hair
parameters via phototrichogram picture analysis (fig. 2). Addition-
ally after 6 months of treatment a retrospective questionnaire was
performed. Methods used enclose both subjective and objective
parameters, reliable methods to assess hair loss and hair growth
parameters to monitor response of therapy [4, 8, 11, 16].
Volunteers were randomly assigned to placebo (1/3 of volunteers of
each sex) or verum* group (2/3 of volunteers of each sex). Demo-
graphic data were assessed with a questionnaire. Regarding age,
volunteers between 30 and 67 years participated in the trial. Women
were significantly younger compared to men (p=0,0389) with 48,5 ±
11,0 years and 54,4 ± 11,0 years, respectively. However, the sub-
groups regarding gender and preparation showed no significant dif-
ference in age (p = 0,1304). BMI was distributed quite homoge-
neously between study groups. Noticeable is the high fraction (31,5
%) of subjects with BMI > 30 kg/m
, termed as overweight. However,
looking at outcome parameters, these volunteers did not show out-
standing differences to other volunteers. In total, volunteers build a
representative group for examination of intended objectives.
Compliance and compatibility
Compliance visits took place every month. Compliance of intake of
test preparations was very good. Tolerance was very high. Only a few
volunteers disliked the strong smell of fenugreek which reminds to
lovage. To mimic the smell in placebo capsules a fenugreek aroma
was added. In both groups only a very few volunteers reported an
unpleasant smell / belch / feeling after intake of study preparations.
This especially occurred, if preparations were taken after over night
fast without breakfast. Volunteers in the trial were asked to take the
preparations in the morning together with breakfast. No other side
effects were reported in relation to the intake of study preparations.
Satisfaction of preparations was quite high, 72 % and 86 % of volun-
teers in placebo and verum group, respectively, would recommend
product to others and most of them (85 % and 90 %, respectively)
would take the product further on.
Hair loss / hair growth parameters
Volunteers with slight to moderate hair loss were enclosed to the
trial. Hair loss was assessed according to a scale of 0–4 (0: none,
1: very slight, 2: slight, 3: moderate, 4: strong); placebo: 2,06;
verum: 2,31 (baseline values). After 6 months of intake of test prepa-
rations, hair loss was significantly improved p < 0,0001 in both
groups; placebo: 0,39; verum: 0,37 (dermatologist assessment).
Data are confirmed by volunteer assessment. With both study prepa-
rations improvement in hair loss was observed over treatment phase.
The trial was performed as double-blind study design to control for
psychological influence. However, the placebo effect is high and
intensively developed for some parameters. Anyhow, clear conclu-
sions can be stated from the clinical trial. The placebo effect is
reflected in other placebo controlled trials . To mimic the intense
smell of fenugreek in placebo capsules, a fenugreek aroma was
added. However, it was not possible to get an aroma completely free
of saponins. Therefore it cannot ruled out, whether small amounts of
saponins could have contributed to the positive effects.
Sex specific differences in baseline values were obvious especially
for the ratio counts anagen/telogen counts. Men: 1,63 (placebo
ig. 2: Picture analysis prior (left) and post treatment (right) with Bockshorn
Mikronährstoff Haarkapseln Arcon-Tisane
lus over a period of 6 months.
equivalent to 62 % anagen hairs) and 2,03 (verum equivalent to 67 %
nagen hairs); women 4,69 (placebo equivalent to 82 % anagen
airs) and 5,43 (verum equivalent to 84 % anagen hairs). However,
changes over time depending on treatment were comparable
between gender groups. For evaluation of statistical significance,
parameters of picture analysis and dermatologist/volunteer assess-
ment were evaluated for preparations but not in gender subgroup,
because of small falling number. Hair density parameter from image
analysis (fig. 2) was significantly improved (p < 0,045; baseline ver-
sus all treated assessment times) over time in comparison to base-
ine data after intake of verum preparation. Maximum hair density
as observed after intake of capsules for four months. Both, hair
density and thickness anagen hair showed diminishing values after 6
months compared to 4 months. Here the seasonal shedding of hairs
could have interfered with the study design.
The parameter hair density was also evaluated via subjective volun-
teer assessment which confirmed the results of picture analysis. The
results clearly show superiority of the verum preparation over the
placebo preparation for the parameter hair density. With the placebo
preparation no significant improvement could be documented over
total treatment phase. Verum preparation showed significant influ-
ence (p < 0,001) on the growth rate of anagen hairs with lowest lev-
els prior treatment. The ratio of anagen/telogen hair counts resulted
in improvement for the benefit of anagen hairs after intake of verum
preparation. However, differences over time were not statistically
After intake of study preparations over a period of 6 months, volun-
teers were asked to evaluate retrospective subjective changes of
parameters according to a scale of –4 up to +4 (1: slight, 2: moder-
ate, 3: medium, 4: strong). Negative numbers referred to worsening,
positive numbers to improvement of parameters. Besides hair
growth parameters, nail parameters were evaluated with this retro-
spective subjective questionnaire. Statistical evaluation was per-
formed gender specifically as the subjective assessment of parame-
ters showed that between genders different problem areas are
defined and evaluated differently between gender groups.
After intake of verum preparation, 82,9 % of volunteers reported an
improvement for the parameter hair volume and hair thickness. 74,3 %
reported an improvement of resistance of hairs. Significant prepara-
tion differences (placebo versus verum) were found for hair dressing
in women (fig. 3) and hair thickness, hair density at parting region
(fig. 4) and hair growth at receding brow in men for the benefit of
verum preparation. Evaluating all observed hair parameters with
clustering in worsening and no change (scale: –4 to 0) versus
improvement (scale: 1 to 4) resulted in significant (p < 0,05) differ-
ences between placebo and verum preparation.
In respect of nail health, volunteers mentioned changes especially in
nail growth and robustness of nails (fig. 5). The parameter robust-
ness was significantly improved after intake of verum preparation
compared to placebo (p < 0,003 for total group). The results indi-
cate, that intake of a supplement containing fenugreek and micronu-
trients could come along with positive changes with related tissues
like nails and skin.
Context of literature
Commercially different therapeutics on the field of medical and sup-
plemental area are available. These preparations are used as topical
or oral applications. In the field of pharmaceutical products, Finas-
terid and Minoxidil are the best known preparations [7, 9, 15, 17].
Finasterid, a competitive inhibitor of type 2 5-alpha reductase
inhibits the transformation of testosterone to dihydrotestosterone
Fig. 3: Retrospective assessment of changes in hair dressing of women on a
scale of –4 to +4; depicted are relative frequencies. p < 0,017.
Fig. 4: Retrospective assessment of hair density at parting region of men on a
scale of –4 to +4; depicted are relative frequencies. p < 0,047.
Fig. 5: Retrospective assessment of robustness of nails in women on a scale of
–4 to +4; depicted are relative frequencies. p < 0,022.
Hair density at parting region
obustness of nails
relative frequency (%)
relative frequency (%)
relative frequency (%)
Kosmetische Medizin –
Organ der Vereinigung für Ästhetische
Dermatologie und Lasermedizin e.V.
Organ der Deutschen Gesellschaft für
Organ der Österreichischen Gesellschaft
für Ärztliche Kosmetologie und
Altersforschung der Haut
27. Jahrgang, Heft 4, 2006
Brandenburgische Straße 18
Vorsitzender des Verlagsbeirats
Dr. Eduard Grosse
Prof. Dr. med. Uwe Wollina
Hautklinik des Krankenhauses
Telefon: 03 51/4 801210
Telefon: 0 30 /88 67 49-30
Fax: 0 30 /88 67 49-99
Nach Tarif Nr. 25 vom 1. 11. 2003
Abonnements und Vertrieb
Telefon: 0 30/88 67 49-30
Fax: 030/88 67 49-99
Jährlich € 68,– inkl. MwSt.,
€ 10,20 Versandkosten;
für Mitglieder der Organschaften
im Mitgliedsbeitrag enthalten.
€ 15,– inkl. MwSt.,
€ 12,20 Versandkosten
6 x im Jahr
Spreedruck GmbH, Berlin
(DHT). Androgen-dependent process in hair loss are predominantly due to the binding of DHT to
he androgen receptor. The hormone-receptor complex activates the genes responsible for the
radual change of large terminal follicles to miniaturized follicles [12, 14]. Minoxidil an adeno-
sine triphosphate sensitive potassium channel opener has been reported to stimulate the pro-
duction of vascular endothelial growth factor in cultured dermal papilla cells.
Since the clinical success rate of treatment of hair loss with modulators of androgen metabolism
or hair growth promoters is limited, further possible cofactors are discussed. One approach is a
sustained microscopic follicular inflammation considered as a possible cofactor in the complex
aetiology of androgenetic alopecia . The approach of dietary supplements with focus to sup-
ort hair growth with different plant extracts, vitamins, trace elements, have shown comparable
ositive effects compared to drugs with the advantage of no side effects. This outlines good
alternatives for persons with slight to moderate hair loss.
The data support, that treatment with fenugreek containing food supplement* results in
favourable effects on hair loss that contribute to improvements in hair growth observed in
treated volunteers. Fenugreek is used in a physiologic dosage of 300 mg extract, equivalent to
1200 mg fenugreek seeds. Therewith, efficacy of Bocks-horn+Mikronährstoff Haarkapseln Arcon-
plus, a fenugreek seeds extract containing food supplement, could be documented in
women and men with low to moderate hair loss.
Address of Correspondence
* Bockshorn + Mikronährstoff Haarkapseln Arcon-Tisane
1 Ahmadiani A, Javan M, Semnanian S, Barat E, Kamalinejad M (2001) Antiinflammatory and antipyretic effects of
Trigonella foenum-graecum leaves extract in the rat. J Ethnopharmacol 75: 283-286.
2 Benedetti F, Mayberg HS, Wager TD, Stohler CS, Zubieta JK (2005) Neurobiological mechanisms of the placebo effect.
J Neurosci 25: 10390-10402.
3 Bin-Hafeez B, Haque R, Parvez S, Pandey S, Sayeed I, Raisuddin S (2003) Immunomodulatory effects of fenugreek
rigonella foenum graecum L.) extract in mice. Int Immunopharmacol 3: 257-265.
4 Chamberlain AJ, Dawber RP (2003) Methods of evaluating hair growth. Australas J Dermatol 44: 10-18.
5 Courtois M, Loussouarn G, Hourseau C, Grollier JF (1994) Hair cycle and alopecia. Skin Pharmacol 7: 84-89.
6 Courtois M, Loussouarn G, Hourseau C, Grollier JF (1995) Ageing and hair cycles. Br J Dermatol 132: 86-93.
illez RL, Jacobs JP, Szpunar CA, Warner ML (1994) Androgenetic alopecia in the female. Treatment with 2 % topical
minoxidil solution. Arch Dermatol. 130: 303-307.
8 Hoffmann R (2002) TrichoScan. A new instrument for digital hair analysis. Hautarzt. 53: 798-804.
Jacobs JP, Szpunar CA, Warner ML (1993) Use of topical minoxidil therapy for andro genetic alopecia in women.
Int J Dermatol 32: 758-762.
Kammerer S, Schilcher H (2003) Praxisleitfaden Phytotherapie. 2. Auflage, Urban & Fischer bei Elsev.
Pierard GE, Pierard-Franchimont C, Marks R, Elsner P (2004) EEMCO guidance for the assessment of hair shedding and
alopecia. Skin Pharmacol Physiol 17: 98-110.
12 Price VH (2003) Androgenetic alopecia in women. J Investig Dermatol Symp Proc 8: 24-27.
13 Sharma RD, Raghuram TC, Rao NS (1990) Effect of fenugreek seeds on blood glucose and serum lipids in type I
diabetes. Eur J Clin Nutr 44: 301-306.
14 Trueb RM (2002) Molecular mechanisms of androgenetic alopecia. Exp Gerontol 37: 981-990.
Van Neste D, Fuh V, Sanchez-Pedreno P, Lopez-Bran E, Wolff H, Whiting D, Roberts J, Kopera D, Stene JJ, Calvieri S,
Tosti A, Prens E, Guarrera M, Kanojia P, He W, Kaufman KD (2000) Finasteride increases anagen hair in men with
androgenetic alopecia. Br J Dermatol. 143: 804-810.
6 Van Neste MD (2002) Assessment of hair loss: clinical relevance of hair growth evaluation methods.
in Exp Dermatol 27: 358-365.
17 Whiting DA, Jacobson C (1992) Treatment of female androgenetic alopecia with minoxidil 2 %. Int J Dermatol 31: 800-804.
Yelne MB, Sharma PC, Dennis TJ (2002) Database on Medicinal Plants used in Ayurveda. Central Council for Research in
Ayurveda & Siddha, New Delhi Volume 4